Common Mistakes of Employee Recognition Programs at Large Companies

Many large organisations often make mistakes—some big, some small—that undermine the effectiveness of their recognition strategies. Let’s take a look at some of the most common recognition mistakes we see and offer you some ideas on how to avoid them.

9 Common Employee Recognition Mistakes

Lack of integration

One of the most common employee recognition program mistakes we see is when companies haven’t taken the time to fully integrate recognition capabilities into the tools their employees use every day. When we say integrated, we mean seamless, easy, and intuitive. Employees shouldn’t have to leave their preferred workflow to give and receive recognition.

Organisations that create exceptional company cultures ensure that recognition is embedded into their culture. This type of highly integrated recognition has a powerful impact on organisations.

When recognition is integrated, it happens frequently for a variety of accomplishments, large and small, and comes from both leaders and peers. It’s personalised for the individual, seen across the organisation, and the tools to give it are updated often.

Culture Cloud, for example, is a powerful recognition platform designed for large companies that integrates seamlessly with many of the apps your employees use every day, such as Teams, Slack, Outlook, Sharepoint, and many more.

Infrequent recognition

Many organisations save their employee recognition for a once-a-year event, like Employee Appreciation Day. And when it comes to budgeting, some spend too little, often on small, generic trinkets, while others spend extravagantly—but no more effectively—on cash incentives, gift cards, or awards.

Research on gift-giving shows expensive, infrequent gifts do not have the long-term impact one might expect. Smaller gestures given more often, over time, are much more meaningful and valued—especially if they’re personalised. The same proves true with employee recognition.

Frequent, tailored recognition experiences spread throughout the year have a larger, more lasting impact on morale and workplace culture than singular company-wide, all-employee events, no matter how much organisations spend.

The Harvard Business Review reports, “According to the data we collect on leaders across industries, every measure of morale, productivity, performance, customer satisfaction, and employee retention soars when managers regularly provide recognition. And, yet, there are many leaders out there who fail to do it frequently or skillfully.”

Employee recognition should be an ongoing process rather than a one-time event. Frequent recognition creates a culture of appreciation and reinforces positive attitudes consistently across the organisation.

Generic appreciation

One common mistake is offering generic recognition without clearly specifying the reason behind it. General statements like "good job" or "great work" lack the necessary detail to help employees feel truly appreciated for their contribution.

Instead, recognition should be specific, detailing the particular achievements and work that deserve acknowledgment. Here are some employee recognition prompts to get you started.

Providing specific feedback not only improves fulfillment, but it also helps employees understand what they did well and encourages them to continue making great work. This is especially true at large companies where employees may have a harder time feeling connected to company leadership, values, and goals.

Lack of connection

Every recognition moment is an opportunity to connect the experience to your organisation’s purpose, mission, and values. Linking great work to the company's mission helps employees understand the significance of their contributions. This reinforces how they fit into the overall success of the organisation.

By reinforcing the connection between individual achievements and organisational objectives, employees are more likely to feel valued and fulfilled. This type of intentional recognition is essential to building a stellar work culture.

Forgetting recognition preferences

Not all employees have the same preferences when it comes to appreciation. While some may appreciate public recognition, others might prefer private recognition or tangible rewards. It is crucial to understand personal preferences and reward employees accordingly.

Regularly seeking feedback and conducting surveys can provide insights into the types of recognition that resonate most with employees, allowing you to customize your program and make it more effective.

Lack of authenticity

Employee recognition should not feel transactional or forced. Yet, all too often this still happens in today’s workplace.

Make the recognition personal. Just as you get to know about your employees’ preferences for recognition moments, you should seek to truly know them as people and what they value. Add sincere touches to their recognition moments that help them know you’re celebrating what they specifically bring to the team.

Gallup notes that “the most effective recognition is honest, authentic and individualized to how each employee wants to be recognized.”

Every recognition moment should be fully personalised for each employee, which can help them feel seen and valued.

Impersonal recognition

Another common mistake is leaving recognition responsibility solely on HR or upper management. Effective employee recognition programs require active involvement from managers and supervisors.

Learning how to properly recognise an employee is critical to a manager’s success—to build trust, loyalty, and engagement.

Managers have direct interactions with their team members, making them the best person to observe and appreciate great work. When managers actively participate in the recognition process, it strengthens the relationship between employees and their supervisors and reinforces the importance of recognition throughout the organisation.

Dropping a gift on someone’s desk when they’re not around is impersonal and ineffective. You don’t have to interrupt their whole day, but employees—and their coworkers—should clearly know when they are being celebrated.

Invite the larger team to participate. If the person giving or receiving the award isn’t in an office, share virtual recognition with an eCard or send something to them in the mail. You can still gather coworkers and recognise great work over a video call.

Unclear criteria for rewards

Another problem with employee recognition programs is not having any specific criteria for recognition.

On the flip side of frequent recognition is the fact that your rewards programs can become random and meaningless if you recognise anything and everything. This can also be an opportunity to set the standard for great work at your organisation and let employees know what to aspire to.

If the criteria for recognition and rewards is unclear, it can lead to confusion and frustration among employees. Organisations should clearly communicate the criteria, expectations, and guidelines for recognition to ensure fairness and transparency.

Sharing success stories and celebrating achievements across the organisation creates a positive and supportive work environment.

Lack of training

This should be obvious, but one easy, crucial step is often overlooked:

Simply take the time to train your people.

To create a truly exceptional work culture, organisations should train leaders and all team members about the role of recognition, including:

• Why recognition matters
• How to personalise recognition in a meaningful way
• Why recognition is important for both large and small accomplishments
• Why recognition should be a priority
• How to give recognition intentionally
  

Companies should emphasize how to give holistic, personalised recognition, focusing on the impact of recognition and providing guidance for creating meaningful recognition moments for all employees.

Integrated recognition makes a difference

Through the years, when it comes to bad recognition practices, we’ve heard it all. Stories of managers who mispronounced employee names, recognized the wrong anniversary year, or confused employees with a random, unclear note left on their desk.

But, what we’ve seen much more of are incredible success stories and thriving work communities where happy employees take the time to appreciate each other with sincerity and ease. Stories of connection, camaraderie, teamwork, and belonging.

Your recognition program is a powerful tool. Above all, keep it real. Keep it genuine. And watch your people thrive.

See how Culture Cloud can help you build a strong workplace culture and improve business outcomes.